Pages

Tuesday, January 24, 2006

Mr. Bell's secret fertilizer

Those of you with children may be familiar with the songs of Raffi. I like Raffi. I may be a bit tired of him after listening to him for almost 6 years, but he remains a decent fellow in my opinion. Some of his songs are downright fun like "Bananaphone;" others, more serious, convey his respect for nature. Some are full of lessons and meaning and others are empty but entertaining. Yet all of them are acceptable for listening. There remains one song, though, that I can't figure out. "The Changing Garden of Mr. Bell" is a haunting little number about a man who has a colorful and everchanging garden in his yard. Seems innocent enough, right? And it could be until our attention is called to a photo on Mr. Bell's mantle that pictures what may be his missing wife and child:

I once saw a photograph, upon his mantle shelf
Of a beautiful lady, a child in her arms
And the young Mr. Bell himself
I wondered out loud about them, and he answered
In the strangest way,
He just said "look, see how the garden grows,
It's always changing ev‘ry day"

from The Changing Garden Of Mr. Bell
(Janice Hubbard/Michael Silversher)


Do you get the feeling that Mr. Bell might have some skeletons in his garden? You might think that I'm reaching but for the closing lines of the song:

Life's a mystery, full of secrets that might tell
In the changing garden of Mister Bell

Convinced now? It gets even weirder:

See the sun through the curtain lace
Dapple his face and hands

What man in his right mind has lace curtains? Clearly there's something very wrong with Mr. Bell. And I'm left wondering what a song about a man who possibly murdered and buried his wife and kid in his garden is doing on a children's album. What was Raffi thinking?

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

I thought the same thing!!!

I try to get my wife to understand my thought process on those exact lyrics & she said "why would they put it on a kid's record then?"

I say it's subliminal messages from Mr. Bell.... >:)

Anonymous said...

I, too, found this song sad and mysterious when I heard on the Bananaphone CD when my son was small, but I think you both have really misinterpreted it.

I had relatives like Mr. Bell -- European immigrants who came to this country after suffering terribly during World War II. Their homes were decorated in a formal European-style (sort of Victorian era), hence the lace curtains. They also would NEVER discuss what they suffered, but did have pictures of their families that were destroyed.

So here's my interpretation: Mr. Bell lost his wife and child during the war. He will not discuss what he suffered with his casual visitor. But he finds his life's meaning in the garden he tends -- in the way it is beautiful and in the way it changes and rejuvenates. He finds solace in this, and that's all he can say to his visitor.

Mindy said...

Whatever helps you sleep at night.